| 名义保费(保单利益基准) | $3,000,000 | $3,000,000 |
| 限时保费折扣 | 10% | 6% |
| 优惠期 | 10月11日 | 10月11日 |
| 实付保费 | $2,700,000 | $2,820,000 |
| 每年提取(第 5 年起) | $240,000 | $240,000 |
| 占实付保费比例 | 8.89% | 8.51% |
| 保费回本年度(不提取口径) | 第 5 年 | 第 4 年快 1 年 |
| 不提取 · 100 岁保单价值 | $279,442,903 | $279,440,949 |
| 提取至 100 岁 · 累计领走 | $16,320,000 | $16,320,000 |
| 提取至 100 岁 · 账户剩余 | $2,840,065 | $9,351,062多 $651万 |
| 领取 + 剩余 · 合计拿走 | $19,160,065 | $25,671,062 |
| 100 岁 IRR(按实付保费算) | 6.81% | 6.70% |
IRR 以期初实付保费为期初投入计算。两家的「不提取」长期价值几乎相同(第 100 岁相差 $1,954), 差别主要出现在「每年提取」这一动作之后 —— 提取会按比例减少保单的名义金额,两家对名义金额减少后的价值计算机制不同。
| 保单年度 | 年龄 | 友邦 财富盈活 | 太保 世代悦享3 | 差额(太保−友邦) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 29 | $1,710,310 | $900,000 | −$810,310 |
| 5 | 33 | $3,489,257 | $3,314,280 | −$174,977 |
| 10 | 38 | $4,989,053 | $4,667,823 | −$321,230 |
| 15 | 43 | $6,919,666 | $6,880,665 | −$39,001 |
| 20 | 48 | $9,864,863 | $9,897,387 | +$32,524 |
| 25 | 53 | $14,200,710 | $14,213,565 | +$12,855 |
| 30 | 58 | $19,843,101 | $19,843,020 | −$81 |
| 35 | 63 | $27,186,769 | $27,186,648 | −$121 |
| 40 | 68 | $37,248,229 | $37,248,066 | −$163 |
| 45 | 73 | $51,033,302 | $51,033,063 | −$239 |
| 50 | 78 | $69,920,047 | $69,919,692 | −$355 |
| 55 | 83 | $95,796,524 | $95,796,009 | −$515 |
| 60 | 88 | $131,249,540 | $131,248,776 | −$764 |
| 65 | 93 | $179,823,244 | $179,822,109 | −$1,135 |
| 70 | 98 | $246,373,429 | $246,371,763 | −$1,666 |
| 72 | 100 | $279,442,903 | $279,440,949 | −$1,954 |
不提取的情况下,两家长期价值基本重合(100 岁相差不到 0.01%)。也就是说 —— 差别不在「放着不动」,而在「怎么领」。
| 保单年度 | 年龄 | 友邦 财富盈活 | 太保 世代悦享3 | 差额(太保−友邦) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5 | 33 | $3,249,257 | $3,074,280 | −$174,977 |
| 10 | 38 | $3,284,362 | $3,093,498 | −$190,864 |
| 15 | 43 | $3,220,692 | $3,318,959 | +$98,267 |
| 20 | 48 | $3,241,148 | $3,518,978 | +$277,830 |
| 25 | 53 | $3,323,247 | $3,767,867 | +$444,620 |
| 30 | 58 | $3,402,691 | $3,974,173 | +$571,482 |
| 35 | 63 | $3,392,012 | $4,142,735 | +$750,723 |
| 40 | 68 | $3,392,524 | $4,362,968 | +$970,444 |
| 45 | 73 | $3,367,608 | $4,656,084 | +$1,288,476 |
| 50 | 78 | $3,338,524 | $5,050,802 | +$1,712,278 |
| 55 | 83 | $3,283,917 | $5,586,228 | +$2,302,311 |
| 60 | 88 | $3,211,285 | $6,315,624 | +$3,104,339 |
| 65 | 93 | $3,092,360 | $7,311,852 | +$4,219,492 |
| 70 | 98 | $2,928,918 | $8,674,447 | +$5,745,529 |
| 72 | 100 | $2,840,065 | $9,351,062 | +$6,510,997 |
提取之后两家的曲线才分开:友邦在前段略高(第 5 年起点 $3,249,257 对 $3,074,280, 领先最多时第 6 年高 $209,855),太保从第 14 年(42 岁)起反超, 之后差距逐年放大,到 100 岁是 $2,840,065 对 $9,351,062。 原因是保单每年被领走 $240,000 后,名义金额会按比例减少;两家对「减少后的名义金额如何继续累积」的机制不同,68 年复利下来就放大了。